Discovering the Best Pets in The Sims 4: A Comprehensive Ranking

  • Adam Mitchell
  • 455
Discovering the Best Pets in The Sims 4: A Comprehensive Ranking

The Sims 4 has been a delight for pet lovers with its numerous expansion packs offering a diverse array of pets that can add joy, companionship, and excitement to the lives of Sim families. Each pet brings unique characteristics, behaviors, and challenges, making the game more dynamic and engaging. To help you choose the perfect pet for your Sim family, we've ranked all the pets available in The Sims 4. Read on and find out which pet has been rated the best based on user reviews.

11. Hamster - My First Pet Stuff


Hamsters in The Sims 4 are cute, tiny pets that are perfect for those who prefer low-maintenance companions. They are part of the 'My First Pet Stuff' pack and require only a small living space in the form of habitat. Sim families can watch as their hamster navigates a tiny world of tubes, wheels, and hiding spots. Hamsters are generally easy to care for, making them a good choice for busy Sims or those who are new to pet care. However, their impact on gameplay is relatively limited, as interactions with hamsters are minimal compared to larger pets.

10. Rat - My First Pet Stuff


Rats are another small pet option available in the 'My First Pet Stuff' pack. Much like hamsters, rats require an enclosure and are easy to maintain. While some players may be hesitant to welcome a rat into their Sim home, these creatures can be quite intelligent and endearing. Rats offer a similar gameplay experience to hamsters, with minimal interaction options. Nevertheless, they are ideal for players who want a low-key pet experience or those looking to add a touch of quirkiness to their Sim household.

9. Pygmy Hedgehog - My First Pet Stuff

Pygmy Hedgehog

For Sims who want a small pet with a unique twist, the Pygmy Hedgehog from the 'My First Pet Stuff' pack is an ideal choice. These tiny, spiky creatures come with their own habitat that includes a wheel for exercise and other accessories. Pygmy Hedgehogs are low-maintenance pets that add a unique and adorable touch to any Sim home. Like the hamster and rat, the Pygmy Hedgehog doesn't have a significant impact on gameplay as interactions are limited. However, their adorable appearance sets them apart from other small pets in the pack.

8. Bubalus - My First Pet Stuff


Bubalus are unusual pets introduced in the 'My First Pet Stuff' pack, resembling a cross between a buffalo and a guinea pig. They are low maintenance and come with their own habitat, similar to other small pets in the pack. Bubalus is a quirky and unique option for players looking to add an unconventional pet to their Sim household. Although their interactions are limited compared to larger pets, their peculiar appearance makes them a popular choice for those seeking a touch of whimsy in their Sims' lives.

7. Birds - Cottage Living


The 'Cottage Living' expansion pack brings a variety of birds to the world of Sims, including chickens, ducks, and wild birds that can be found throughout the Henford-on-Bagley neighborhood. Sims can build a coop for their chickens and ducks, where they can lay eggs and be cared for. Additionally, wild birds can be interacted with by placing bird feeders in the yard. Interacting with birds helps Sims build relationships and can even lead to befriending them. Birds add a charming touch of nature to the game and encourage Sims to explore their surroundings.

6. Rabbits - Cottage Living


Rabbits in the 'Cottage Living' expansion pack can be found hopping around the picturesque countryside of Henford-on-Bagley. Sims can interact with wild rabbits and, depending on the relationship level, might even convince them to help with gardening or provide gifts. This adds a fun and endearing aspect to the game and encourages Sims to form connections with nature. Rabbits are an excellent addition to a Sim family seeking the joys of country living without the responsibilities of pet ownership.

5. Chicken - Cottage Living


Chickens in The Sims 4 'Cottage Living' pack are versatile pets that can provide valuable resources to Sim homes. Sims can build a chicken coop, keep chickens, and collect fresh eggs daily. Chickens can also be cared for, fed, and cleaned, offering players a more engaged pet experience. They can even have different personalities, making each chicken unique and interesting. Chickens are an ideal pet choice for players who want a more immersive rural life experience for their Sims.

4. Cow - Cottage Living

Cow - Cottage Living

Cows, introduced in the 'Cottage Living' expansion pack, bring a new level of interaction and care to the game. Sims can milk cows, feed them, and clean their stalls to keep them happy and healthy. Players can also enter their cows in the Henford-on-Bagley Cow Fair, showcasing the bond between the Sim and their bovine companion. Forming a close relationship with a cow can result in better-quality milk, which in turn can be used to create various recipes. Cows are perfect pets for Sims who love the rural lifestyle and want to immerse themselves in the ups and downs of farm life.

3. Llama - Cottage Living

Llama - Cottage Living

Llamas are an entertaining and quirky addition to the 'Cottage Living' expansion pack. These amusing pets can be kept in a barn, where Sims can shear them for wool and care for them through feeding and cleaning. Sims can even dress up their llamas in custom outfits, making them true fashion icons of the Henford-on-Bagley village. Players looking for a fun, interactive pet experience while embracing rural life will enjoy having a llama as part of their Sim family.

2. Cat - Cats and Dogs

Cat cat and dog

Cats, as part of the 'Cats and Dogs' expansion pack, offer a wide range of breeds and customization options to suit any player's preferences. Each cat comes with its own unique personality traits, making them an engaging and entertaining pet. Cats can be trained, played with, and cuddled, forging deep connections with their Sim owners. Their mischievous antics and endless curiosity make cats a beloved choice for players who want a pet that adds excitement and unpredictability to their Sim family's life.

1. Dog - Cats and Dogs


Dogs hold the top spot in our ranking based on user reviews. The 'Cats and Dogs' expansion pack introduced a diverse array of dog breeds, allowing players to find the perfect canine companion for their Sims. Dogs can be trained, taken for walks, and played with, enhancing the bond between Sim and the pet. Each dog has unique traits, making their personalities as varied as those of the Sims themselves. Dogs can protect their owners, offer emotional support, and provide endless entertainment. Their loyal and loving nature makes them the ultimate pet choice for players seeking to make their Sims' lives richer and more fulfilling.

In conclusion, The Sims 4 offers a pet for every player, whether they're searching for a loyal companion, a mischievous sidekick, or a unique creature to care for. Based on user reviews, dogs in The Sims 4 have emerged as the best pet option, thanks to their varied personalities, strong bonds with their owners, and significant impact on the gameplay experience. Regardless of the pet you choose, you're sure to find the perfect addition to make your Sim family's life even more enjoyable.